Welcome to the Podiatry Arena forums

You are currently viewing our podiatry forum as a guest which gives you limited access to view all podiatry discussions and access our other features. By joining our free global community of Podiatrists and other interested foot health care professionals you will have access to post podiatry topics (answer and ask questions), communicate privately with other members, upload content, view attachments, receive a weekly email update of new discussions, access other special features. Registered users do not get displayed the advertisements in posted messages. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our global Podiatry community today!

  1. Have you considered the Clinical Biomechanics Boot Camp Online, for taking it to the next level? See here for more.
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Have you considered the Clinical Biomechanics Boot Camp Online, for taking it to the next level? See here for more.
Dismiss Notice
Have you liked us on Facebook to get our updates? Please do. Click here for our Facebook page.
Dismiss Notice
Do you get the weekly newsletter that Podiatry Arena sends out to update everybody? If not, click here to organise this.

The influence of body posture and added mass on intrinsic and extrinsic foot muscle activation...

Discussion in 'Biomechanics, Sports and Foot orthoses' started by scotfoot, Mar 16, 2026.

  1. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member


    Members do not see these Ads. Sign Up.
    What am I missing here ? My understanding was that during quiet standing tension in the plantar fascia will generate a degree of digital purchase in the toes( torque around the MTPJs).

    If you stand on one leg and lean forwards you will generate greater tension in the plantar fascia and hence ,via the plantar plates, greater digital purchase ( greater MTPJ torque).

    In the study linked to below, surely leaning forwards will increase the tension in the plantar fascia and hence the torque around the MTPs compared to not leaning forwards, right across the range of exercises tested.

    The influence of body posture and added mass on intrinsic and extrinsic foot muscle activation and force output during common foot strengthening exercises

    John W A Osborne 1, Hylton B Menz 2, Karl B Landorf 2, Glen A Whittaker 2, Matthew Cotchett 2, Luke A Kelly 3
    Affiliations Expand
    Free article
    Abstract

    Background: Intrinsic and extrinsic foot muscles contribute to foot and lower limb function. This knowledge provides opportunities to target these muscles in exercise and rehabilitation. However, a barrier is the limited understanding of how prescribed exercises affect muscle activation and force output. This study examined muscle activation and torque production about the metatarsophalangeal joints of intrinsic and extrinsic foot muscles during common foot strengthening exercises. The secondary aim was to determine whether the addition of a postural change (leaning forward) or addition of mass can further increase muscle activation and torque.
    Methods: Fifteen healthy participants (nine males, six females; age = 36.5 ± 8 years, mean ± SD) participated. Muscle activation was measured using fine-wire electromyography (EMG) electrodes for two intrinsic and two extrinsic muscles, and surface EMG electrodes for four superficial muscles. Metatarsophalangeal joint torque was measured using a custom toe dynamometer. Participants attended one 90-min session and performed 16 exercises. Five included the addition of leaning forward and three the addition of mass (20% of participant's mass) to compare their effects on muscle activity and torque.
    Results: Muscle activation and metatarsophalangeal joint torque varied considerably across exercises. Both the addition of leaning forward and the addition of mass increased muscle activation and metatarsophalangeal joint torque, with the addition of leaning forward producing a 35% median increase in torque about the metatarsophalangeal joints.
    Conclusion: Many common exercises, despite high muscle activation, produce relatively low metatarsophalangeal joint torque, raising questions about their clinical value. Adding a forward lean significantly increases toe flexor muscle activity and torque, reaching levels greater than added mass and comparable to walking.
     
  2. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    The reverse windlass mechanism has been discussed before on podiatry arena .Here is a quote from Craig Payne -

    "On weightbearing, the windlass unwinds as the arch flattens and the foot elongates. This is seen to place a compressive force upon the posterior and anterior struts of the ‘truss’ structure of the foot, which produces tension in the plantar aponeurosis ‘tie-rod’. This causes a powerful plantarflexory force to the proximal phalanges, as the insertions of the aponeurosis’ digital slips is wound around the plantar surface of each metatarsophalangeal joint to attach to the base of the proximal phalanges. "

    In Osborne et al 2025 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2025.101110 , the authors have considered the effects of adding mass and a forward lean, both of which will act to increase tension in the plantar fascia producing an increase in the plantarflexory force to the proximal phalanges( torque at the MTPJs ) .

    When considering torque the authors have omitted the effects of the reverse windlass first suggested by Wicks 70 odd years ago, indeed the plantar fascia ,a key player in foot mechanics, is not mentioned in the paper at all. What has happened here?
     
  3. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    A major problem when measuring toe flexor torque /power around the MTPJs is taking into account what the toe interproximal joints are doing.

    If we press our toes down hard, and the lumbricals and interossei are weak, then the toes will adopt a hammertoe configuration. The mechanics of this configuration are very different than if the IP joints did not buckle under load especially with regard to tension in the plantar plates.

    I have taken to saying that toes which buckle under load but which are not in a deformed configuration when not under load show " functional lesser toe deformity" . Functional lesser toe deformity is not the same as flexible lesser toe deformity which may well be one stop further down the line.

    Susan Mayes has long advocated calf raises as a rehab/ prehab exercise but with an emphasis on keeping the toes straight at the IP joints.
     
  4. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    Susan Mayes was head physio at Australian Ballet and was conspicuously successful when it came to helping her dancers avoid or recover from injury . She used calf raises to strengthen the ankle planter flexors and separate intrinsic foot muscle exercises for these muscles. My understanding is that she has recently started using banded flexion exercises for the hallux and 5th toe in preference to exercises like the short foot exercise.

    Elsewhere, Torstein E. Dæhlina et al 2023, studied weighted calf raises performed over 11 weeks and found that "No changes were observed in the ankle plantar flexor or II-V digit flexor strength (n > 0.05). "

    Osborne et al found that "The exercises with the highest mean EMG RMS amplitude were: single leg heel raise for AH (57.6% ± 19.7%), hallux flexion for FHB (62.5% ± 24.7%), and the single leg heel raise for FDB (58.1% ± 20.6%)."

    So adding a forward lean to the single leg calf raise does not increase mean muscle activation in the AH or FDB. One might speculate that given weighted calf raises do not increase 2-5 digit flexor strength ( Daehlin ) and leaning calf raises activate the FDB to a lesser extent than calf raises without a lean (Osborne), calf raises of any type are not a good way of strengthening the lesser toes.
     
  5. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    In Osborne et al 2025, single leg calf raises showed higher activation without a forward lean than with a forward lean for the intrinsic foot muscles .
    Osborne-
    "The exercises with the highest mean EMG RMS amplitude were: single leg heel raise for AH (57.6% ± 19.7%), hallux flexion for FHB (62.5% ± 24.7%), and the single leg heel raise for FDB (58.1% ± 20.6%)."

    A very recent study demonstrated that single leg calf raises , even done on an inclined plane, do not increase toe flexor strength. Specific, targeted, exercises do.

    Paper
    The Effect of Targeted Toe Flexor Training on Muscular Strength and Jump Performance in Adolescent Ballet Dancers: A Randomized Controlled Trial
    Anna Schrefl, PhD et alOnlineFirsthttps://doi.org/10.1177/1089313X261420458

    Key Points

    •Targeted toe flexor training using progressive resistance in a dorsiflexed position significantly improved toe flexor strength within 6.5 weeks, exceeding minimal detectable change thresholds and outperforming both the heel rise and control groups.

    •Foot-specific resistance training also produced the greatest improvements in horizontal jump performance, suggesting a beneficial carryover to dance-specific performance tasks.•

    IMO the evidence indicates that calf raises are a poor way of strengthening the intrinsic foot muscles or even the long toe flexors.

    Tourillon et al used sled pushes and calf raises and it is highly likely any strength gains were due to the sled pushes . In rugby ,props have strong toe flexors in my experience. The toes of professional front row players stay straight under load .
     
  6. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    Looking further at Osborne et al, it would appear that of all the exercises tested, the short foot exercise, toe press etc ,with or without added mass or a forward lean, the exercise that gives the greatest activation of the flexor digitorum brevis muscle (FDB) is the single leg calf raise without forward lean .

    Torstein E. Dæhlina et al 2023 has shown that this exercise does not produce an increase in lesser toe flexor strength and so presumably does not strengthen the FDB . So what works? Toe curls? Well, the research shows toe curls activate the FDB less than exercise without flexion at the interproximal joints, for example, the toe press.
     
    Last edited: Oct 8, 2026
  7. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    When considering toe flexor strength, I have seen few trials that take into account the shape of the toes as they are pressed down. It seems to be unimportant to most researchers whether force is delivered via straight toes , or clawed/ hammered toes . ( IMO toe flexor strength trials where strength is measured by toe curling activities are of limited value)

    Lesser toes which buccal under load tell a different story to toes which remain straight at the interphalangeal joints and ,IMO, indicate weakness in the interossei and lumbricals since these muscles both help press the toes down and extend the interphalangeal joints.

    But how do you exercise the toes in such a fashion as to promote straight toes and produce effective activation of muscles like the lumbricals and interossei ? Well, I think the answer lies, at least in the initial stages of strengthening , in using none weight bearing, toe flexion exercises where the plantar fascia is not highly loaded and the forces generated in the muscles of the toes tend to straighten them.

    For example ,the theraband exercises used by researchers such as Mickle and Mayes.
     
  8. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    Imagine a person stands, then squats down a little . Now, they gently exert pressure through their leg muscles and stand back up straight . Now imagine they position themselves under a stationary bar set an inch or two under shoulder height . They duct under it and press up against the bar . They can now generate much greater ground reaction forces under their feet than they could without the bar to work against.

    IMO, this is similar to the situation we see when toes which lack strength in certain muscle groups are pressed down( lumbricals and interossei for example ) . When generating ground reaction forces, the flexor digitorum longus ,coupled with the flexor digitorum brevis, pull the distal and interproximal bones of the lesser toes "in under" the proximal phalanx causing it to dorsiflex. The tension in the plantar fascia acts to resist the dorsiflexion of the proximal phalanx and this gives the FDB and FDL something to work against . But this is far from optimal . Strong lumbricals and interossei act to plantarflex the proximal phalanx at the MTPJ and extend the toes at the interphalangeal joints . This means that the FDB and FDL no longer act to dorsiflex the proximal phalanx but instead act to plantarflex it.

    In lumbrical/interosseus deficient feet, the amount of ground reaction force that can be generated under the toes is limited by the counter forces being generated in the proximal phalanx by tension in the plantar fascia .

    Leaning forwards, as subjects do in some exercises seen in Osborne et al, gives greater tension in the PF and so ( see analogy) can assist the generation of greater ground reaction forces under the toes. A forward lean based exercises may be a good way of strengthening the foot but only if any lumbrical, interosseous weakness is addressed first, IMO.

    A diagram summarising the concept of functional lesser toe weakness is attached below .



    upload_2026-10-11_10-42-1.jpeg
     
  9. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    People reading this thread may wonder why I have not talked about the lesser toe extensor muscles, after all, it is common to talk about lesser toe deformity being caused by an imbalance between the flexors and extensors . The reason is that during gait "their biomechanical contributions may be largely separable from each other"

    From Zelik et al 2016 Coordination of intrinsic and extrinsic foot muscles during walking
    Karl E Zelik 1, Valentina La Scaleia, Yuri P Ivanenko, Francesco Lacquaniti

    "Conclusions:
    The sequential peak activity of MTP flexors followed by MTP extensors suggests that their biomechanical contributions may be largely separable from each other and from other extrinsic foot muscles during walking. Meanwhile, the task-specific coordination of the foot muscles during other modes of locomotion indicates a high-level of specificity in their function and control."

    Obvious extensor tendon activity during quite standing may represent later stage compensation with intrinsic flexor muscle deficits being the initial culprit in some cases.
     
  10. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    The interosseous muscles of the foot, taken together as a unit, make up about 20% of the intrinsic foot muscle mass whilst the abductor hallucis makes up less , about 17% .

    The origins of the plantar and dorsal interossei are the metatarsals and tissues proximal to the tarsometatarsal joints ,such as the long plantar ligament . It is thought these muscles can support the longitudinal arch by opposing extension of the forefoot on the midfoot/rearfoot. I think it is reasonable to assume that they also create a tie beam across the lesser metatarsals, when they contract , helping to stiffen the foot through toe off, and so reduce tension in the plantar fascia .

    Toes which buccal into a hammer toe configuration under load likely have reduced input from the interossei . I have never seen a study, which looked at the role of foot weakness in plantar fasciitis, that considered the interossei .

    20% of total intrinsic mass left out of the equation !
     
  11. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    Anatomists studying the interossei came to the following conclusions -

    1 "Their positions and time of contraction during the gait cycle imply a possible role as stabilisers of the forefoot, rendering the tarsometatarsal joints rigid when weight is carried on the ball of the foot."

    IMO rendering the tarsometatarsal joints rigid likely helps take load away from the plantar fascia.

    The study of 10 sample feet also found that in all cases, a slip of the 1st dorsal interosseus muscle arose from the tendon of the peroneus longus. This slip gave rise to "much of the medial head" of this muscle.
    The origins and function of the interosseous muscles of the foot.
    P J Kalin 1, B E Hirsch 1
    PMCID: PMC1261748 PMID: 3654378
    Abstract

    The dorsal and plantar interosseous muscles of the foot arise, not only from the metatarsal bones, but also from ligamentous tissue proximal to the tarsometatarsal joints. The interossei also take origin from the fascia of adjacent muscles, and the first dorsal interosseous muscle usually arises in part from a slip of the peroneus longus tendon. A means may thus exist to ensure that the interossei contract in a coordinated manner. Their positions and time of contraction during the gait cycle imply a possible role as stabilisers of the forefoot, rendering the tarsometatarsal joints rigid when weight is carried on the ball of the foot.
     
    Last edited: Oct 28, 2026
  12. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    The transverse arch plays a huge role in maintaining longitudinal arch stiffness during gait . Although the met heads remain on the same transverse plane and are not at all "stacked" the evidence shows that the action of the trans metatarsal tissues helps project the transverse arch from the midfoot into the forefoot .

    Simply wrapping the forefoot in elastic has been shown to increase foot stiffness ( see below) . Muscles can do this job ie adductor hallucis and the interossei . When I flex my toes using these muscles the metatarsals are pulled together (see video)

    In chronic plantar fasciitis the muscles of the forefoot have been found to be smaller than in healthy feet, Chang et al .

    Transverse contributions to the longitudinal stiffness of the human foot

    Ali Yawar, Lucia Korpas, Shreyas Mandre, Madhusudhan Venkadesan
    Humans rely on foot stiffness to withstand the propulsive forces of walking and running. Skeletal adaptations that increase foot stiffness include the medial longitudinal arch (MLA) and the transverse tarsal arch (TTA). The TTA has been hypothesized to stiffen the foot through cross-axis coupling of transverse intermetatarsal stiffness with sagittal-plane midfoot stiffness, but this has been tested only in cadaveric specimens. In vivo testing is essential because muscle contraction substantially modulates MLA function and may similarly affect the TTA's cross-axis coupling. Here we provide in vivo evidence for the TTA's contribution to foot stiffness by externally increasing intermetatarsal stiffness and measuring its effects on midfoot elasticity during walking. As predicted by the cross-axis coupling hypothesis, increasing intermetatarsal stiffness with an elastic tape wrapped around the forefoot reduced the energy absorbed in midfoot flattening and increased sagittal-plane midfoot stiffness concomitantly (mean,±,standard error of the mean (SEM): 13.9%±3% and 16.8%±5.8%, respectively).

    ​
    [​IMG]
    0:05
    0:00 / 0:07
    Video link
    https://youtube.com/shorts/AGGsiqx

    How do you strengthen these muscles . Moving your toes from extended to flexed against resistance would do the job.
     
  13. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    A paper has just been published that looked at the effects of wearing special elasticated socks that help reduce forefoot splay during gait ( the socks act to narrow the foot at the level of the met heads ) .

    The socks produced a 65% increase in medial longitudinal arch stiffness. I believe that in the unshod foot, foot splay is probably held in check by the adductor and interosseus muscles as well as the transverse metatarsal ligament.

    "2. Results
    Foot-stiffening socks mitigated forefoot splay and stiffened the medial longitudinal arch. Foot-stiffening socks applied approximately 24 times more pressure to the forefoot than control socks ( d = 3.77, p < 0.001, 95% CI = 155, 178; gure 2A). In turn, foot-stiffening socks reduced standing forefoot splay ( d = 0.48, p = 0.011, 95% CI = − 0.5, − 0.1) and elicited 10% narrower feet versus the use of control socks ( d = 1.47, p < 0.001, 95% CI = − 1.1, − 0.7; gure 2B,C ). Through cross-axis coupling, foot-stiffening socks increased medial longitudinal arch stiffness by 65% versus the use of control socks."

    Foot-stiffening socks reduce the metabolic cost of walking

    Proceedings of the Royal Society B
    • November 2026
    • 293(2082)
    DOI:10.1098/rspb.2026.1467 License CC BY 4.0Authors:Hui Tang Owen Beck
     
  14. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    Further to the origin and actions of the interosseus muscles, it seems probable that they also act to pull the metatarsals closer together when activated in close chain, this despite their low pennation angle.

    If strategically elasticated socks can reduce forefoot splay giving a narrower forefoot and a reduce "metabolic cost of walking" then why has the foot not evolved to be narrower than it is? There are probably a number of reasons including absorbing impact forces during weight acceptance.

    I would contend that the foot has evolved to splay during weight acceptance then narrow during toe off, and that the narrowing of the ball of the foot ( or at least resistance to foot splay) is achieved by a combination of muscular contraction and the effects of the geometry of the metatarsal parabola in acing in conjunction with the transverse metatarsal ligament.

    IMO the muscles primarily involved in narrowing the foot, by approximating the metatarsals, are likely the adductor hallucis and interossei . It may also be worth noting that the pennation angle of the dorsal interosseus muscle fibres is likely significantly higher during forefoot splay.
    [​IMG]
     
  15. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    It seems generally accepted that during weight acceptance the met heads can separate from each other a little in the transverse plane giving splay, mobility in the midfoot, and energy storage/dissipation. I believe the evidence supports the idea that as gait progresses through toe off, the geometry of the metatarsal parabola ,acting in concert with the transverse ligament (see videos) causes the met heads to move closer mediolaterally but further apart antero-posteriorly. This narrows the foot anteriorly causing a general stiffening effect in the foot . So from mobile adaptor to stiff lever as required .

    The muscles of the forefoot likely contribute to the effect since the interosseus muscles and adductor hallucis both flex the toes and act towards resisting foot splay .

    It's about basic geometry and in fairness I have been saying this for years!
    Transverse arch of the foot ( hand as analogy )


    www.youtube.com › shorts › LW-FOcEpMwI

    upload_2026-11-9_10-40-23.jpeg
    0:10
    Tips of fingers represent met heads of foot and area under elastic band represents midfoot . During push off and as the heel rises, ...
    YouTube · Gerrard Farrell · 27 May 2020

    And second video link showing met heads and transverse ligament model
    https://youtube.com/shorts/MPTYdPIit_4?si=eX6xginvJ6QWQzCI
     
  16. scotfoot

    scotfoot Well-Known Member

    Based on Tang and Beck then, placing elastic around the ball of the foot to draw the met heads together can increase the stiffness of the medial longitudinal arch by 65% . That's a lot.

    Anecdotally, when I press my toes down my foot narrows, since the adductor hallucis and interossei both flex the toes and more closely approximate the met heads. For me, this raises the interesting prospect that the muscles of the forefoot might contribute more to foot stiffness than all the other intrinsic foot muscles combined. Increased medial longitudinal arch stiffness probably means less tension in the supporting plantar fascia.

    A recent study showed a significantly lower muscle volume in the forefoot of patients with plantar fasciitis.

    Could researchers be focusing on the wrong muscle groups when considering plantar heel pain and the intrinsic foot muscles ?

    Here is a link to a short section on youtube that shows toe flexion narrowing the forefoot.
    The action of the adductor hallucis during toe flexion .


    www.youtube.com › shorts

    [​IMG]
    0:07
    The action of the adductor hallucis during toe flexion . It acts to flex the great toe and pulls the met heads together.
    YouTube · Gerrard Farrell · 13 May 2023
     
Loading...

Share This Page